
Personal Finance
Stock-Linked Bonds Offer Downside Protection
By Tara Siegel Bernard Dow Jones Newswires
781 words
8 July 2004
The Wall Street Journal
D2
English
(Copyright (c) 2004, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.)
For investors still smarting from any bear-market-related trauma,
several new stock-debt hybrid products have hit the market in recent
months, offering some downside protection.
These equity-linked notes are essentially interest-bearing bonds that
are linked to an underlying stock. Once the notes mature -- assuming
they haven't been called early -- holders will receive shares of the
underlying stock based on a predetermined exchange ratio. The
trade-off? Though your downside is cushioned by the interest payment --
typically in the 8% to 10% range -- your potential for investment gains
is capped.
"You are in effect loaning money to the firm, and what you will get in
return is based on the performance of an underlying stock the firm
chooses," said Richard Mikaliunas, head of the capital-markets group at
the American Stock Exchange, where the majority of these notes are
listed.
These products are geared for more conservative individual investors
looking to preserve their capital, but who, at the same time, still
want to keep a toe dipped in the stock market. Of course, they should
also find the underlying stock attractive.
"These were not very popular when the market was roaring, [though in]
the past couple of years they have come back into favor," Mr.
Mikaliunas added.
The notes, which have existed for about a decade, are issued by many of
the large Wall Street firms such as Morgan Stanley, Merrill Lynch &
Co. and Citigroup Inc., to name a few. The notes' inherent risk is tied
to the health of the underlying issuer.
Morgan Stanley recently issued what it calls "SPARQS", or Stock
Participation Accreting Redemption Securities, tied to Yahoo Inc. and
Avaya Inc., while Merrill Lynch recently issued its product, called
"STRIDES," or Stock Return Income Debt Securities, tied to Sony Corp.'s
American depositary receipts. A full roll of recent offerings listed on
the American Stock Exchange can be found under the structured-products
tab at www.amex.com, along with other structured-product offerings.
Here's how they work, using Morgan Stanley's 10% SPARQS exchangeable
for shares of JetBlue Airways as an example (they expire on June 15,
2005).
In this case, the JetBlue SPARQS -- equity-linked notes traded like
stocks -- cost $14.15, which is equal to half of the stock's official
close on May 21, when they were initially offered for sale. The notes
pay 10% interest on the principal amount -- it's paid quarterly,
beginning Sept. 15 -- and at maturity, investors receive half a share
of JetBlue for each SPARQS held. However, investors' total returns,
including interest, cannot exceed 34%.
Investors do run the risk of having their notes called early, cutting
their potential earnings short. In the case of the JetBlue SPARQS, all
of the SPARQS can be called at any time beginning Nov. 30. Holders
would be paid the amount of interest that has accrued during the period
they held the notes, along with a predetermined call price.
Investors must also be mindful of the fact that they don't actually own
the shares. So if a particular stock began paying a dividend,
equity-linked note holders wouldn't benefit.
Though it doesn't apply to the JetBlue SPARQS example, equity-linked
notes in some cases don't pay investors interest until they mature.
It's best to hold those in a tax-deferred account, such as an IRA,
because Uncle Sam doesn't want to wait for his money. Indeed, investors
have to pay tax on the so-called estimated phantom income that they are
expected to receive at the end of the note's term, before they actually
receive it.
Maturity dates typically run between one and three years, while the
notes' prices relatively track the price of the underlying stock, Mr.
Mikaliunas said. Regular investors should be able to trade the notes
easily. But large institutions looking to trade 5,000 share blocks
could run into liquidity problems; the instruments are not geared for
that market, he added.
Meanwhile, many of these equity-linked products can be similarly
re-created by individual investors through the purchase of the stock
and call options. However, that could become pricey for the smaller
investor, given that they would be paying for the call, in addition to
the commissions. Doing it yourself also doesn't provide the interest
income.
"None of these are beyond the more sophisticated investors, but you
have to go out and do it," Mr. Mikaliunas said. "The other part is that
it becomes too commission intensive for the smaller investor, and that
can [eat] away at your return."
Document J000000020040708e0780002f