The Kellogg 2018 Super Bowl Ad Review

Kellogg Super Bowl Ad Review 2017

Why some brands score big and others fumble badly

Each year, brands spend upwards of $2 billion collectively on Super Bowl commercials. Some emerge as clear winners. Others limp away. This year, for the fourteenth time, Kellogg School of Management marketing students will apply rigorous, research-based criteria to determine what separates the Super Bowl advertising winners from the losers.

2018 Results coming soon.

Winning plays. 6 research-based criteria for scoring the ad

On Super Bowl Sunday, Kellogg MBA students work side-by-side with two of Kellogg’s most widely respected marketing professors, Tim Calkins and Derek Rucker, to apply the strategic ADPLAN framework to evaluate an ad’s ability to build its brand against six critical criteria: Attention, Distinction, Positioning, Linkage, Amplification and Net Equity.
Super Bowl Scoring Ads

Meet the experts behind Kellogg Super Bowl Ad Review

The Kellogg School Super Bowl Advertising Review panel comprises Kellogg Marketing Club students, led by two of Kellogg’s most widely recognized marketing professors, Tim Calkins and Derek Rucker.
Tim Calkins

Tim Calkins

Clinical professor of marketing

Award-winning teacher, author and consultant on marketing strategy and branding to major corporations, Professor Calkins compiled the first Super Bowl Advertising Review in 1999 and launched it in its current format in 2005. About Super Bowl ads, he says, "Creativity is great, and popularity is great, but at the end the day advertising has to build the business."
Derek Rucker

Derek Rucker

Sandy and Morton Goldman Professor of Entrepreneurial Studies in Marketing

Co-developer of the ADPLAN framework, which emphasizes the assessment of advertising from a strategic perspective, Professor Rucker teaches advertising strategy and is frequently cited in major media outlets. He focuses his research on understanding what makes effective advertising communications and the motives underlying consumer consumption.


Taryn Tawoda
Associate Director, External Communications Email Taryn 847.467.1492
Molly Lynch
External Communications Email Molly 773.505.9719

Kellogg on Branding

Executive Education
Kellogg continues to write the book on marketing and branding. Learn how to put our world-class thought leadership and real-world insights to work in your company.